Meet the Prairie Grove Insurance Team

Your Guide for the Years Ahead

Prairie Grove Insurance was built on a simple idea: people deserve a trusted advisor who listens more than they talk.

Founded in 2011, Prairie Grove Insurance was built on a simple idea: people deserve a trusted advisor who listens more than they talk. We take immense pride in the quality of service we provide to our customers.

As independent brokers, our loyalty is strictly to our clients, not the insurance companies. Our primary goal is to educate you so you can make the most informed decisions about your health insurance coverage. Whether you need help filing a claim, processing a payment, or simply understanding your coverage, we'll always be ready to help.

We know our clients and we know insurance. You can enjoy the peace of mind that comes with knowing your agency can help you regardless of how small, big, unique, or specific your needs are. With the years of experience we bring to the table, there isn't much we haven't seen before.

Best of all, our services are completely free. Thanks for taking the time to learn more about our agency—please give us a call anytime to see how we can help you!

Carrie Davies

Agency Owner

Email: [email protected]

Founded in 2011, Prairie Grove Insurance was built on a simple idea: people deserve a trusted advisor who listens more than they talk. As independent brokers, our loyalty is strictly to our clients, not the insurance companies. We take immense pride in the quality of service we provide, and best of all, our services are completely free.

At the helm is Agency Owner Carrie Davies, who is committed to making insurance feel less complicated and more personal. With experience across all aspects of the agency, Carrie brings a well-rounded understanding of both the insurance landscape and the people she serves. Her approach mirrors the agency’s core philosophy: listen first, educate when needed, and help clients feel confident in the decisions they make.

Together, Carrie and her team aim to be your guide for the years ahead. Whether you are comparing coverage options, navigating a claim, processing a payment, or simply asking a question about your policy, we are always ready to help. We know our clients and we know insurance, giving you the peace of mind that comes with knowing your agency can handle your needs, regardless of how small, large, or unique they may be.

Our ultimate goal isn’t just to provide insurance; it’s to be a trusted resource our clients know they can always turn to.

Ethan Davies

Licensed Agent

Email: [email protected]

Ethan Davies is a licensed insurance agent with Prairie Grove Insurance who genuinely loves helping people make sense of their coverage. He knows insurance can be confusing, so he takes a straightforward, educational approach to make sure his clients always feel comfortable and confident in their choices.

For Ethan, it’s all about building real relationships and offering the kind of dependable service you can actually count on.

When he’s not helping clients plan for the future, you can usually find him outdoors. He’s a big fan of snowboarding, hiking, and just hanging out with his family and his dog, Spike.

Whether you need help with a new policy or are looking ahead to retirement, Ethan is here to be a trusted resource for you and your family.

Julie Elfers

Customer Relations Manager

Email: [email protected]

With years of experience as a small business owner and photographer, Julie brings a unique blend of professionalism, creativity, and attention to detail.

As a mom of three, she knows the importance of making informed decisions for the future and is passionate about helping others navigate important choices - especially when it comes to Medicare.

Business Hours

Mon: 9:00 AM – 5:00 PM

Tue: 9:00 AM – 5:00 PM

Wed: 9:00 AM – 5:00 PM

Thu: 9:00 AM – 5:00 PM

Fri: 9:00 AM – 5:00 PM

Sat: Closed

Sun: Closed

LOCATIONS

Prairie Grove Insurance
5231 Voges Rd

Madison, WI 53718

Questions? Call us now:
(800) 254-5200 / (608) 839-0275

This is a solicitation for insurance. Submitting information or calling numbers listed on this website will direct you to a licensed Agent/Broker.

Important disclosures about Medicare Plans: Medicare has neither endorsed nor reviewed this information. Not connected or affiliated with any United States Government or State agency. We do not offer every plan available in your area. Any information we provide is limited to those plans we do offer in your area. Please contact Medicare.gov or 1-800-MEDICARE to get information on all of your options.

Copyright 2026. All Rights Reserved.